Edge of the Fall (Part 1)

(A SHORT NOVEL )

I started traversing the trail up the mountain, which I often visit whenever I want to be alone to meditate or contemplate. Sometimes, I come here to read a book, and because I always bring a pen and a notebook, there have been times when I have journaled. This mountain is where I retreat whenever I need to make a significant decision, just as I did today.

I travel for an hour by bus to get here. It will take almost 2 hours of walking at a normal pace to reach the mountain’s highest point. No one knew that I had gone to this mountain.  Anyway, I never told anybody that I come here occasionally. That is intentional. It’s my hideaway, so I kept it secret. Even this climb, no one knows. I haven’t told anyone that I’m going anywhere… and I won’t be coming back.

I’ve been walking for quite a while now, and it’s already past noon. But I only feel a few sweat drops on my forehead and cheeks. I don’t even feel any dampness at the back of my shirt. Even though my backpack is heavy, it is filled with food and drink for my last supper. It could be because my steps are small. It’s like the walk of those joining a funeral march to bring someone to their resting place. It’s like the walk of someone about to be executed, needing to be pushed and coerced by those escorting them to the gallows. Or perhaps I’m not sweating much because it’s only late March, and the stubborn winter refuses to give way to spring, much like the emotional winter that still grips my heart and mind, refusing to melt away. The cold still lingers, just as my pain does, and the promise of renewal feels as distant as the warmth of spring.”

The cherry blossoms are starting to bloom in the few trees along my trail, and the leaves are beginning to sprout on the branches of some trees and plants. Under some trees are shrubs of forsythia with their buds of flowers, giving a glimpse of their yellow color. The flowers will bloom to their fullest in just a few days to bring life and color to the surroundings made barren by the scorching chill of the past winter. Yet, even as spring begins to reveal its beauty, I can’t help but feel indifferent. Like the stubborn winter that clings to the earth, my heart refuses to acknowledge the warmth, the hope, and the promise of renewal that is slowly pushing through the cold. The world may be awakening, but it’s still winter inside for me, and I can’t shake the cold rooted deep in my soul.

It’s too bad I won’t be around to witness the full bloom of the flowers as spring unfolds. The trail I’m walking on will be one I won’t descend again. Spring, with its promise of life and renewal, seems so distant, as though it belongs to a world I can no longer be part of. The flowers will bloom, the trees will bud, and life will return to the earth, but it feels as though my winter is too deep to let that warmth reach me. Death, like the last bite of cold in winter, feels inevitable now, and I cannot bring myself to see the beauty of spring when my heart remains frozen in this endless, unyielding chill.

No one knows what will happen when I climb this mountain again. I can’t say I’ll leave it all to fate when I reach the top. Fate is a myth.  I don’t believe when they say  “It is written.” That is not true. The book of life has nothing but empty pages.  I subscribe to the notion that life is the sum of our decisions. We hold the pen and we’re responsible in writing our story in the empty pages of the book of life.

And I have already made up my mind. I will write the last sentence of my storyten at the end of the day. Everything’s planned already. I’ll get to the summit and sit in my favorite spot there to finish a dozen beers and two bottles of Korean wine. I won’t leave any of the fried chicken I brought, except the bones. The peanuts and some kimchi I packed, I’ll gobble them all up, too.  They are the last foods I’ll taste. At least I’ll be full and drunk when I die. It’s not just the ones about to be executed who are given what they want to eat before their sentence is carried out. Even those who are about to take their own life should have their last but sumptuous meal.

This should have been one of the happiest days of my life. I prepared for it and spent a lot of money. I should have been in my own country now. But everything got messed up. Where did I go wrong?

Where did I fall short? I can’t figure it out.

I’ve reached the rocky part of the mountain. Only now did I realize that this part of the mountain looked like a cemetery during such times. There are no trees, and the large rocks resemble tombstones. The plants that haven’t yet sprouted leaves resemble crosses and grave markers.

In any case, the mountains here are often used as burial grounds. Every time I climb this mountain, I pass by a few graves that, without any markers or tombstones, would look like ant hills.

I’ll also lie down here on this mountain. Unfortunately, I won’t be buried properly.

I still have a long way to go, but I don’t want to speed up my steps. I’m not in a rush to die.  I just need to carry out my plan at the top of the mountain. I’m ready. By this afternoon, before the sun sets, the story of my life will be over.

If only I could, to avoid the tiring climb, I would just let myself get run over by a truck. If only I could, I would use a gun or a knife. I’ve thought about doing any of those. But where will I get a gun? I don’t like to knife myself to death, for I think it’s a painful way to die. Even drinking poison. But I don’t want to die that way either. Another thing is, the poison I might buy might not even work. I want to be sure that my breath will stop when I do what I planned to do. If I let myself get run over by a truck, my body would be smashed to pieces, and anyone who picks up my scattered bones and flesh would be disgusted. They’ll swear, for sure. Instead of sympathy, they’ll curse me, and my soul may not find eternal repose. Then I paused, having recalled that, indeed, my soul will be damned in hell, for I am taking away my own life. That’s what my religion taught me. But what’s the difference between the hell afterlife and the hell I am in now?

Above all, the last thing I want is to be a bother to anyone. I don’t want to be found dead and cause trouble for others. I even thought about jumping in front of a subway train. But I don’t wish my country’s name to be dragged into it when the media finds out that the crazy person who got hit by the train was a citizen of my country.

Well, suicide news is pretty common here. If what I read is true, over twenty people commit suicide in this country every day. I will be part of those statistics tomorrow.  So, even if they hear about my death, they probably won’t care. And that’s what I want. I don’t want anyone to notice what I’m going to do. The only one who should know that someone jumped from the highest part of this mountain is the dead person who landed in the rocky, overgrown section of it. But I certainly won’t live to tell the tale. Dead men tell no tales.

Of course, my loved ones, friends, colleagues, embassy officials, and the authorities here will look for me. But they won’t think my corpse is here, in the steep mountain section covered with trees and grass. I even made sure to enter the section of the trail with no CCTV cameras earlier, so there’s no proof that I climbed this. I have been here many times and memorized where those security cameras are installed. That’s part of my planning. When they eventually suspect I could have come here and looked for me, the wild animals that I know roam this area have already filled their stomachs with my flesh, and the worms would have feasted on their leftovers. My bones could be scattered in different places, but the dirt and dry leaves would have already concealed them. They won’t find any of my clothes either because I’ll burn them, and I’ll jump to my death naked. So, if my skull is rigid and doesn’t break when I jump, I’ll surely die from hypothermia. I provide myself with no escape.

That’s how detailed my plan is. I just don’t have a suicide note because I don’t want anyone to know what I’m about to do. And for me, leaving a suicide note is corny.

I decided to take a break for a while. It felt like my legs no longer wanted to move. I sat on a large rock, leaning against a tall pine tree.

The surroundings were quiet. Was it just a coincidence that today, there were no chirping birds in the trees like I used to hear when I came here? Do they know what I am about to do, and in sympathy, they are keeping quiet and watching me from the branches of the trees?

I also didn’t meet anyone on the way up. That was fine, for it meant no one could claim to have seen someone who looked like that person in my photo, which they would surely show when they came searching for me. And I hope there won’t be anyone when I reach the top. I want to jump as soon as I finish all the food I brought, so it can all be over quickly.

While resting, I lit a cigarette. I coughed a bit when I inhaled the smoke. It was my first time smoking. I suddenly decided to do it when I bought a lighter at a convenience store before climbing. I wasn’t afraid of getting lung cancer anymore. It was the fear that prevented me from becoming a smoker.  That fear has lost its fangs, for in just a few hours, I’ll be closing the book of my life. At the convenience store, I ensured that the hood of my jacket covered my head, and I was also wearing a face mask that I usually use for protection against yellow dust, so no one would recognize me if they checked the CCTV, in case they started searching for me.

Before I could finish the cigarette, my phone suddenly rang.

It was my mother calling. I didn’t want to answer, but I wanted to give her the courtesy of hearing my voice one last time.

“Joseph… son, are you okay?”

I could feel my mother’s sympathy for me as she said that. And that’s what I hated the most – being pitied. That’s why I didn’t want to answer her call.

“Don’t worry about me, Mom. I’m okay.”

“Are you sure, son?”

I felt a little bit annoyed with my mother.

“How many times do I need to tell you, Mom?”

“Sorry, I just want to make sure. Son, I hope you still come home, no matter what happened. We miss you. It’s been months since we last saw you.”

It felt like my brows furrowed when I heard that. If I were looking in the mirror, I’d probably see my forehead wrinkled like a tangled pile of noodles. I had no face to show anyone after everything, yet my mother still wanted me to come home! For what? To be pitied or laughed at? To be a topic of conversation among rumor mongers. And if I did go back to the country, I wouldn’t want to go to our house. I’m sure something bad will happen. If I’m not the one getting badly hurt or killed, maybe I’ll be the one to hurt somebody badly or worse, take that someone’s life. Actually, two lives. The idea of going home feels like trudging back into the dead of winter, cold and suffocating, as if the chill will never melt away.

“Sorry, Mom. My boss gave me an urgent task at the hagwon. My contract entails me to abide by it.”

“But aren’t you on leave because supposedly you and Jinky…”

“Mom… STOP… PLEASE.”

Another reason I didn’t want to go home was that event. It was the only thing they would repeatedly talk about. Every time I thought about it, it felt like needles were piercing through my heart and mind, like the sharp, unforgiving frost of winter that cuts through any warmth that might try to reach me. You can call me dramatic, but anyone who has gone through what I did would have their world collapse and come to a halt. I couldn’t even allow myself to believe in the possibility of spring, of things changing, when all I felt was the numbness of winter and the certainty that nothing would ever thaw.

For the first time, I yelled at my mother. When I said those words, I felt like my eyes were about to pop out. It was as if I were talking to my youngest sister.

It took a while before I heard my mom’s voice again.

“Son, if you need someone to talk to, just call me, okay? Or we can Skype.”

“Yes, Mom. I’m sorry. Just let me be for now.”

“By the way, her parents came here earlier. They wanted to…”

“AHHH… MOOOMMMMMM!!! DON’T YOU UNDERSTAND WHAT I AM SAYING? IS IT THAT HARD TO UNDERSTAND WHAT I WANT TO HAPPEN? I WANT ALL OF YOU TO LEAVE ME ALONE.”

“I yelled again at my mother. It felt like my throat was going to explode as I said that. If I were talking to anyone else, not my mother, those words would have been interlaced with a lot of cussing and cursing.

What followed was silence, a heavy pause that seemed to stretch endlessly, like the cold between winter and spring—an unspoken tension, the space where anger and regret collide, where something could change but refuses to thaw.”

“Okay… okay, son.” My mother broke the icy silence, her voice trembling, like the first crack of thawing ice that still clings to the cold, unwilling to fully give way to warmth.

“Ah… Joseph. Son, are you still with me?”

It was the last thread of patience and respect I had for my mother that made me still answer her.

“What is it, Mom?”

“Well, you see…”

I already knew what my mother was going to say.

“Your brother is here. I want you two to talk. I’m begging you.”

The last thread of patience I had snapped. I didn’t respond to my mother’s supplications. I ended the call. That could never happen again – for me to talk to my mother’s eldest son. If by some miracle, my bones and skull weren’t crushed when I hit the rocks and the cold didn’t take my breath away, and I survived, we’d never reconcile.

“It would have been easier to accept what happened if he hadn’t been involved. But of all the people, why my brother? The brother who once promised, when we were little, that he would always have my back. Yeah, he had my back—just long enough to stab me in it.”

My mother kept calling. I didn’t answer. If I weren’t waiting for any other call, I would have turned off my phone and thrown it away. The silence felt colder than the phone buzzing in my hand, like a winter storm that refused to let up, relentless and suffocating.

I had no one on my side. Of course, my mother would favor her favorite child. Maybe my friends understand me. I’m sure they know what happened. It’s hard to believe they haven’t heard. Many of them were even invited to my wedding that was supposed to happen today. There are calls and texts from the country. Some are even sending me private messages on Facebook. My Messenger is flooded with messages, as is my email. Not one of them have I responded to. Their advice and opinions would only make things more complicated. They don’t know what it’s like to feel like you’re stranded alone on a desolate island in the middle of an unyielding winter, no warmth, no escape from the cold.

Whatever they say, it’s still me who will decide for myself. This is my life. I think no one can help me. No one can change what has happened.

What about God? Could He change everything that happened? If only He could. But I know that’s not how God works. He doesn’t interfere. He doesn’t take sides. As I understand it, He lets people make their own decisions and face the consequences of their actions.

When a person is born, the wheel of their fate begins to turn. Sometimes, they’ll get caught in that wheel. It’s too bad if they can’t avoid it and get crushed. Trapped. Crushed. Just like me now. Crushed. Completely crushed. It’s the weight of winter, bearing down, suffocating, unrelenting. No spring in sight to soften the blow, no light to cut through the darkness.

I can’t wait to get to the top of the mountain. I just want to slam my head against the rocks repeatedly until my skull breaks.

To be continued…

Edge of the Fall (Part 1)

The Self-Improvement Paradigm

This video explains my proposed self-improvement paradigm. This conceptual model served as my guide in writing the book “A Paradigm For Self-Improvement.”
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0DT4RGQ9H

The Fabrics of Race (2)

(Second of Three Parts)

Why didn’t my mother at least warn me that I would be shaken by the things I would uncover if I kept digging into the issue of Whites and people of color? But maybe she didn’t answer me because she couldn’t grasp it herself. And if she, an adult, couldn’t, how could I when I was just a clueless teenager?

She was right. It is hard to understand why the White forefathers of Americans brought Africans to their colonies in North America to be slaves, treated them like animals destined to be sold, punished, taken advantage of, or killed for resisting.

It’s unfathomable how a person’s skin color could give someone else the right to mistreat them. Or why being white gave them the freedom to do whatever they wanted.

            Why? Do White people own the world?

When our Philippine History teacher said that Spain and Portugal once divided the non-European world between them, as if they had split the earth like a piece of fruit, I wondered. They agreed on which parts of the world each country could claim as its own.  He said that, actually, Magellan, who discovered the Philippine archipelago, was a Portuguese who circumnavigated the globe on behalf of Spain.

So, aside from the history of the world, I also began reading more about my nation’s history. I tried to learn more about my country beyond what my elementary teachers taught us in our Social Studies classes.  

However, that only raised more questions than it answered my previous ones. I only got more surprised, sometimes shocked. It wasn’t just the Spanish and Portuguese. The British, French, Germans, and other Europeans, all of whom were white, also joined the scramble. Any land their giant ships could reach and batter with their big guns—they claimed it. Whites ruled the world, enslaving people whose skin color was different from theirs.

Why? The whys kept coming.

We were taught in elementary school that the Spaniards, White people from Europe, colonized us. But I didn’t know then that that was for more than 300 years. Yes, three long centuries.  Then, the British tried to seize the Philippines from them but failed. Eventually, it was America that successfully took us from Spain. What was their justification? If they didn’t take us, the Germans would.

So, were colored countries just toys for white nations to pass around?

People of color, black and brown, were treated like animals by the Whites of the West. Their lands were seized. Their resources were stolen. They were driven to forced labor. Some of them were taken as captives and brought to the home countries of the colonizers to serve as slaves.

Some were deprived of the right to establish their destiny as nations. That’s what the Americans did to my forebears. The Filipinos, who were on the verge of toppling their Hispanic colonizers and starting to exist as a sovereign country, were misled into believing that the US was helping them achieve independence from Spain. It turned out to be wishful thinking. The Americans, in pursuit of their imperial ambitions, took the Philippines away from the Spaniards.

Then, I realized something else about reading. It could steal your innocence. Barely in my teens, I felt like I was already losing the purity and simplicity of my perceptions. Sad to say, I started feeling an animosity towards the Whites, particularly those from the Iberian peninsula, the Spaniards, and those from North America, the cousins of the Brits. I was both hurt and angry when I came to know the cruelty my forefathers suffered at the hands of our colonizers, the Spaniards and the Americans. But I was no longer surprised because those who colonized us were Whites, and my forebears were people of color. If the Americans could not treat their Black countrymen justly and humanely, why would they treat an almost equally dark-skinned people like us differently?

I may be young then, but my heart bled with my forebears who bravely fought the Whites, but to no avail, for the latter were far superior in military strategy and weaponry. It wasn’t fair. The Davids don’t always win against the Goliaths. Most of the time, they lose. If it were a boxing match, the colonized people were flyweights, and their colonizers were heavyweights. It wasn’t a fair fight. Only the people of Haiti were able to successfully expel their colonizer, France, at the height of the colonial period. There were a few other nations that succeeded in driving out colonial forces, but these occurred during the 20th century when colonialism was in decline.

There was a price I had to pay for digging deeper after I saw that photo in my mother’s book. I gave up blissful innocence and traded it for a heartbreaking awareness of the past and a worrisome understanding of its impact on the present. Such consciousness of historical truths was painful and has become a burden, but it was necessary. It was only through knowing these dark chapters of history that I could slowly understand human sufferings brought forth by cruelty and injustice that I never thought human beings could inflict on their fellow men. The loss of my innocence is a victory, bittersweet it may be, but the thought that I could do nothing to stop the cruelty and injustice is painful.

*****

In college, I did my laundry, still following my grandmother’s rule: separate the whites from the coloreds and wash black clothes last.

I continued reading about history, both of the world and my country. I became a more avid student of history. I had more books, especially encyclopedias, at my disposal. The Internet was not yet accessible to everyone at that time. It was in those years of self-study and reading about history that I truly began to see the connections between race, power, and oppression. I discovered more horrifying truths about slavery and colonialism.

As I read more, I learned how colonial powers—British, French, Spanish, and some of their white European cousins—used slavery to fuel their economies, treating Africans as property rather than people. The brutal migration of thousands of enslaved Africans to the Americas was not just a historical fact—it was a system built on the idea that people of color were inferior and expendable.

As I explored further into history, I began to also have a better understanding of the scale of the Holocaust, where the Nazis sought to exterminate millions of Jews, just as other racist systems attempted to erase people of color.  My young mind had found it mightily difficult to comprehend why the Germans had such intense hatred towards the Jews in the same vein that I consider unfathomable the belief of white Americans that they are superior to people of African descent and brown-skinned like me.

I tried to read more about that photo showing a massive pit filled with dead bodies, surrounded by tall, white German soldiers who appeared to be grinning as they looked down at the corpses of the Jews they gassed, peppered with bullets, or allowed to die through starvation and sickness. One of them had a gun pointed at the head of a man on his knees whose eyes reflected resignation to his fate, and I was pretty sure that a few seconds after that picture was taken, a bullet crashed through that man’s skull, and probably died even before his body landed in that pit.

I can’t help but ask why again?

Why did the Germans try to erase from the face of the earth the descendants of Abraham? Is it truly a crime to be born with skin darker than the ideal, whether Black, Brown, or Jewish? I couldn’t understand how their belief in the superiority of the  Aryan race gave them the right to eliminate the people of Israel, whom they believed to be racially inferior.

What makes them consider themselves superior, their white skin? As I pondered the answer,  I couldn’t help but playfully correlate melanin to racism. Could it be that the less melanin in the skin, the more racist a person becomes? Could the more melanin a person has, the more likely they will be oppressed?

There were times when I wanted to stop reading. It made me think that sometimes ignorance felt comforting. As they say, “Ignorance is bliss.” Would it have been better for me not to have chanced upon my mother reading that book and seeing that photo?

But it was too late for me to turn my back on reading. Reading has become an itch that I needed to scratch. It is the drink that quenches my thirst for the answer to the question of why the whites were so cruel and brutal. Why did they see dark-skinned people as less than human, treating them like animals on leashes?

It isn’t comforting to think that the practice of abusing and maltreating a group of people was considered acceptable among the White population. And here, again, are my whys. Why was such treatment of fellow human beings allowed? Why did the society of white people sanction such cruelty?

And what I consider most appalling was the defenders of slavery providing religious justification. Yes, even the Holy Book was used to sort people like garments. Just as white fabrics were given special treatment and black ones were washed last, so too did the disciples of slavery use scripture to divide, dominate, and dehumanize. The Bible, which is supposed to inspire equality and compassion, was instead twisted by those who tried to justify slavery. Slave owners and colonizers clung to verses that appeared to endorse servitude while ignoring the spirit of liberation that is a more compelling theme of the Holy Scriptures.

Yes, slavery was mentioned in the Bible, and even regulated. However, we must remember that the prophets and apostles who wrote these sacred texts were, like us, human beings. They were not infallible. They lived in societies where slavery was the norm, and their words were shaped by the flawed realities of their time. Blindly accepting slavery as morally permissible just because it existed in scripture is to confuse description with prescription and culture with divine command.

The more profound message of scripture, primarily through Christ, is one of love, justice, and human dignity. That message was silenced by those who preferred “Slaves, obey your masters” over “Love your neighbor as yourself.” Faith was weaponized. In the hands of slave masters, the  Bible, became not a source of hope but a whip. And those who used it to subjugate others were not spreading the gospel. They were staining it.

Why didn’t the Whites chose to love their dark-skinned neighbors? What have people of color done to them to deserve such hatred? Why were they dehumanized? Why did White people perpetuate the inhuman system of slavery for centuries? I continued reading to find answers to the many questions I had. I wanted to understand the psychological mechanism of slavery and its lingering effect on the ongoing systems of racism and inequality. I tried to find the roots of the hatred that Caucasians harbor toward people of color.

The more I uncovered in my readings, the more I realized that understanding the roots of such hatred of the Aryans toward dark-skinned people was not just about finding answers; it was about understanding the complexities of human nature. It was about confronting the darkness of human history and understanding its unshakable grip on the present.

And as I continued through the pages of both our nation’s history and that of the world, I kept repeating one question:

WHY?

Why is it that in every photo that struck me, there were always fair-skinned, tall people standing triumphantly or towering over dead bodies of people with colored skin?

Why were American soldiers even photographed, smiling, hands on their hips,  at the edge of a mass grave filled with the bodies of brown-skinned Filipino Muslims whom they massacred at Bud Dajo in Sulu?

It would’ve made sense, although not morally justifiable, if they had only killed soldiers or warriors. But they included helpless women and children. You can even see in the photo dead women with their breasts exposed. Didn’t those American soldiers in the photo and their commanding officers have no sisters, wives, aunts, mothers, or grandmothers? Why did those American soldiers do it? Was it because my forebears were dark-skinned and thus didn’t deserve to live?

Then I unearthed more photos, those of dead colored people again, including children and women, massacred in Shaperville in South Africa. They belonged to the group that protested against the restriction on movement imposed upon them. Reports had it that they were sprayed with bullets by the White police who belonged to the White government that subjected their non-white compatriots to political, social, and economic discrimination.

It made me wonder if the Apartheid that the Whites in South Africa implemented was inspired by the segregation scheme that the white Americans used against their colored compatriots. It appeared to be so. Similar to what their fellow Whites did in America, the White supremacist government of South Africa declared certain areas as white-only zones, forcibly relocating colored families to slum areas far from their schools and workplaces. Who wouldn’t protest?

I saw no difference between the images of the Holocaust and those of the massacres at Bud Dajo and Sharpeville. All displayed the same cruelty that humans can inflict on one another. And I couldn’t help but notice that the perpetrators in these cases were fair-skinned, blinded by their belief in white supremacy, while their victims were dark-skinned souls.

Why does history repeat itself? Why, in every conflict, in every atrocity, do the perpetrators so often share the same trait—whiteness—and their victims, a common heritage of darkness?

What about the abuses of the South African white government during the implementation of apartheid? What about the abuses committed by the Americans when they colonized my nation? What about the atrocities committed by other colonizers in the countries they occupied during the colonization period?

Ah, there’s a legal technicality, they say. Something called the Genocide Convention — the act of genocide is only considered a crime if committed after 1948. So, it’s too bad for the people of color who were victimized before the world decided to classify such things as illegal, immoral, and criminal.

What about the guilty parties in the implementation of Apartheid in South Africa? That was after 1948, right? While some individuals were reportedly prosecuted, the larger question of criminal accountability for apartheid-era crimes remains a complex and unresolved issue in that country.

*****

Then, I became a teacher and eventually got married.  The laundry was no longer my concern. My wife did it, and she was just as meticulous as my grandmother was with the fabrics.  She treated the whites delicately and ensured that the colored ones were strictly separated.

During my first year of teaching, aside from English, I was elated when our High School principal assigned me the courses of Philippine History and World History. These courses seemed drawn to me. Even when I eventually moved to a tertiary institution, I would be assigned those courses. Slavery, colonialism, racism, and other related constructs would always come knocking at my doors. Strangely enough, even when I taught at the Graduate School level, I found my way back to history when I was asked to teach Southeast Asian studies.  And what’s the common denominator among Southeast Asian countries? They were all colonized by the Whites, except for Thailand. There was no place in the world that the Caucasians from  North America and Europe did not include in their collection of trophies. Every country they successfully invade is a trophy.

I taught History passionately, and whenever the subjects of slavery, colonialism, and racial discrimination were discussed, either as the main topics or as related topics, I became like a man possessed. I poured out all the thoughts and feelings I had been carrying in this writing.

I argued with my students that there is a need for the countries of the civilized world to convene again in Geneva and once and for all create laws intended to address the abuses committed by imperial forces during colonial times in countries they occupied by force.

The Fabrics of Race (3)

The Fabrics of Race (1)

The Fabrics of Race (1)

(First of Three Parts)

“Separate the whites from the colored fabrics.”

I was just a little boy when I first heard those words. That was my grandmother’s strict instruction to our housekeeper whenever it was time to do the laundry.

“Scrub the whites, but carefu. Make sure all the stains are gone,” added my mother’s mother, a woman known for her slight sternness. “And don’t forget to bleach them.”

 My curiosity wasn’t about her sternness but about the special treatment given to white clothes. Why couldn’t they be mixed with the colored ones? After all, they were just clothes. They were but the same.

Then came my grandmother’s final warning: “Wash the black clothes last. Never, ever mix them with the whites. You’ll be in big trouble with me if you do.”

That lingered with me. White clothes required special care. Never mix them with colored ones during laundry to avoid stains. And the black clothes? They had to be washed last, not with the white or other colored clothing. Even when rinsing, black and other colored items must be done last, using water that has already been used for the whites.

Poor colored garments, especially the black ones.

The way colored fabrics were treated struck me, and later, it connected to something that had confused me deeply as a child. It happened when I asked my mother about a photo in a book she was reading. I cannot recall the title, but it was about American history.  She had returned to college after we, her children, required less of her attention. She had dropped out of school when she decided to marry my father. Our grandmother and the housekeeper took care of us whenever she attended her classes.

I developed a love for reading at a young age because I saw how much my parents enjoyed it. My father would have an English broadsheet and a Filipino tabloid every morning. On the other hand, my mother read magazines, comics, and her reference books. It was my mother who taught me how to read, a skill I learned even before I started attending school. I often browsed and read the bo0ks she brought home from the library. Both of my parents were my dictionaries. They patiently translated English words into our vernacular whenever I asked.

In the photo I mentioned, I saw the word “restroom” written on a wall, and below it were two signs that read “white” and “colored.”

Before my mother could flip to the next page of the book, I asked her about the picture. “Colored is what white Americans called their fellow citizens with black skin,” my mother explained.

I didn’t know why she laughed when I said, “But white is also a color.” Was I wrong? Why were dark-skinned people called colored and white people were not? Is white colorless?”

She said I was being a bit of a philosopher. She told me I was right — white is a color, too — but I was too young to understand what colored meant in that context.

I looked at my skin then. It was dark brown, just a few shades away from black. One thing was for sure: I was not white. And whenever I played for too long outside on non-school days, my mother would say, “Look at you. You’ve gotten darker from being out in the sun.”

If the world were a giant washtub and I were a piece of laundry, I’d be sorted with the coloreds, not the whites. My skin was only a little lighter than black, so if I were to be rinsed, I would probably be last, too.

Then I asked her, “Do you mean, Mom, the whites and those with dark skin had separate restrooms?” My mother closed the book she was reading, looked at me, and said, “You’re too young to understand.” That was the same thing she said earlier. She kept insisting that I was too young to understand.

When she put down the book beside her, I grabbed it and looked for that photo again. Then I kept pestering her about it until finally, she explained that there was a time in America when black people were not allowed to mingle with their white fellow citizens in public places like restaurants, cinemas, transportation, and even restrooms.

But why?

Then, what my grandmother said about the whites and the colored fabrics echoed in my mind.

I turned to more pages in the book. Even in drinking fountains, it was the same. People with dark skin couldn’t drink from the same fountain as the whites.

Why was that?

Maybe it’s because the whites were afraid they’d get stained if they mingled with people who didn’t share their skin color?

That was, of course, the kind of question a child like me could ask. But was that a silly question?

My mom looked surprised. She didn’t answer immediately. Her eyes narrowed, and then her forehead creased,  just like my classmates’ faces when our teachers called on them unexpectedly, and they didn’t know the answer.

She had difficulty answering my question. She nodded and smiled. I couldn’t say it was a “yes” — it felt more like, “Sorry, I don’t know the answer.” It was the same look I’d give our teachers when I didn’t know the answer to a question — smile, look down, and scratch the back of my head.

My mother knew me well. She knew I was about to bombard her with a barrage of questions. She knew I would not stop asking questions until my curiosity, like thirst, was quenched. But before I could ask another, she beat me to it.

“Someday, you’ll understand why. Now, go play outside. Give me back the book — I need to study.”

*****

When I got to high school, I could still hear my grandmother’s rule echo in my head every time I saw a laundry pile — whites must be separated from coloreds. Black clothes were like lepers, isolated to keep their color from spreading.

At that time, I would hear my mother parroting my grandmother’s instructions about white and colored fabrics when instructing my younger sister whenever they would do the laundry. We no longer had a housekeeper. My parents had started cutting expenses. My grandmother was no longer living with us, so my mother and sister had to do the laundry.

Sometimes, I helped sort the whites from the coloreds before they did the laundry. And every time I did, the images from that book would resurface in my mind — photos showing that in America, people with dark skin were banned from mingling with the whites. I used to think Americans were kind, mainly because my grandmother used to tell stories of how they saved us from the oppressive Japanese during World War II. That changed because of those photos. However, those photos also sparked my interest in reading history books. That’s why, even though I was only in my first year of high school, I was already reading books on World History — a subject we were only supposed to study in our fourth year.

My mother’s responses to the questions ignited by that photo left me hanging. I wanted to know why people with dark skin were treated with such disgust in America and if the same was true in other parts of the world.

Why was that? Did black people do something wrong to be treated the way they were treated? Is it a sin to be dark-skinned? As I continued my education and delved deeper into history, I realized that my grandmother’s instructions about white fabrics and colored ones mirror how society categorizes people based on skin color.

I believed that reading would help me understand why such practices existed in America at that time. But it didn’t. Yes, it was true that the more I read, the more I learned. However, the more I learned, the more confused I became. My questions only multiplied. My thirst for the answers to those questions was never quenched.

I wanted to ask my mother why she didn’t just tell me outright that whites once enslaved black people, and that’s why they were looked down upon.

I learned that the Americans were British colonists who revolted against their king and founded their own nation. The British were the ones who brought dark-skinned people from Africa to North America as slaves to serve and work in their fields.

I recognize how much I didn’t know about the world’s history. So, I read more. That’s when I realized that the more I  read, the more I learned that I was ignorant about many things. That’s when I also understood that reading doesn’t always give you answers — sometimes, it makes you ask more questions. And the answers to your questions can make you wonder, laugh, get angry, disgusted, or even feel pity.

At a very young age, I felt deep pity for black people. While slavery dates back to antiquity, nothing was more pronounced than the plight of dark-skinned slaves. They suffered the most from it. People who were enslaved throughout history were considered inferior, uncivilized, and bestial. No race was stigmatized this way more than people of African descent. A book I read claimed that Americans, in par“Separate the whites from the colored fabrics.”

I was just a little boy when I first heard those words. That was my grandmother’s strict instruction to our housekeeper whenever the latter did the laundry. We didn’t have a washing machine back then.

“Scrub the whites thoroughly but carefully. Make sure all the stains are gone,” added my mother’s mother, who was very strict when it came to household chores, particularly the washing of clothes. “And don’t forget to bleach them.”

  My curiosity wasn’t directed toward her strictness but at the special treatment she gave to white clothes. I wondered why they couldn’t be mixed with the colored ones. After all, they were all just clothes. They were but the same.

Then came my grandma’s final warning: “Wash the black clothes last. Never, ever mix them with the whites. You’ll be in big trouble with me if you do.”

That lingered with me. White clothes required special care. Never mix them with colored ones during laundry to avoid stains. And the black clothes? They had to be washed last, not with the white or other colored clothing. Even when rinsing, black and other colored items must be done last, using water that has already been used for the whites.

Poor colored garments, especially the black ones.

The way colored fabrics were treated struck me, and later, it connected to something that had confused me deeply as a child. That confusion started when I asked my mother about a photo in a book she was reading. I cannot recall the title, but it was about American history.  She had returned to college after we, her children, required less of her attention. She had dropped out of school when she decided to marry my father. Our grandmother and the housekeeper took care of us whenever she attended her classes.

I developed a love for reading at a young age because I saw how much my parents enjoyed it. My father would have an English broadsheet and a Filipino tabloid every morning. On the other hand, my mother read magazines, comics, and books. It was my mother who taught me how to read, a skill I learned even before I started attending school. I often browsed and read the books she brought home from school.

In the photo, I saw the word restroom written on a wall, accompanied by two signs:one white and the other colored. Before my mother could flip to the next page of the book, I asked her about what I saw. “Colored is what white Americans called their fellow citizens with black skin,” my mother explained.

I didn’t know why she laughed when I asked, “But white is also a color. Why were people with dark skin called colored, and White people were not? Is white colorless?” She said I was being a bit of a philosopher. She told me I was right; white is a color, too, but I was too young to understand what colored meant in that context.

I looked at my skin then. It was brown, just a few shades away from black. One thing was for sure: I was not white. And whenever I played for too long outside on non-school days, my mother would say, “Look at you. You’ve gotten darker from being out in the sun.”

If the world were a giant washtub and I were a piece of laundry, I’d be sorted with the coloreds, not the whites. My skin was only a little lighter than black, so if I were to be rinsed, I would probably be last, too.

Then I asked her, “Do you mean, Mom, the Whites and those with dark skin had separate restrooms?” My mother closed the book she was reading, looked at me, and said, “You’re too young to understand.”

When she put down the book beside her, I grabbed it and looked for that photo again. Then I kept pestering her about it, so she had no choice but to explain that there was a time in the US when Black people were not allowed to mingle with their White fellow citizens in public places like restaurants, cinemas, transportation, and even restrooms.

But why?

Then, what my grandmother said about the whites and the colored fabrics echoed in my mind. However, we were discussing people, not clothes.

I turned to the following pages in the book. Even in drinking fountains, it was the same. People with dark skin couldn’t drink from the same fountain as the Whites.

Why was that? Maybe it’s because the Whites were afraid they’d get stained if they mingled with people who didn’t share their skin color? That was, of course, a silly question. The kind of question a child like me could ask.

My mother just nodded and smiled in response to the whys I asked. I couldn’t say if it was a yes, I had the impression that it was more like, “Sorry, I don’t know the answer.” I also had that kind of reaction when I couldn’t answer the questions my teachers asked during class discussions. I would say nothing but smile sheepishly and look down as if begging the floor to rescue me from that embarrassing situation. I would end up just scratching the back of my head.

My mother knew me well. She anticipated I was about to bombard her with more questions. She knew I would not stop asking questions until my curiosity, like thirst, was quenched. But before I could ask another, she beat me to it.

“Someday, you’ll know the answers to your questions and understand why. Now, go play outside. And give me back that book because I need to study.”

*****

When I got to high school, I could still hear my grandmother’s directives echo in my head every time I saw a laundry pile, “whites must be separated from coloreds.”  Black clothes were like lepers, isolated to keep their color from spreading.

At that time, I would hear my mother parroting what my grandmother said about white and colored fabrics when instructing my younger sister whenever they would do the laundry. We no longer had a housekeeper by that time. My parents had started cutting expenses. My grandmother was no longer living with us, so my mother and sister had to do the laundry.

Sometimes, I helped sort the whites from the coloreds while they were doing the laundry. And whenever I did so, the images from that book would resurface in my mind, those photos showing that in the US, people with dark skin were banned from mingling with Whites. I used to think Americans were kind, mainly because my grandmother used to tell stories of how they saved us from the oppressive Japanese soldiers during World War II. That changed because of those photos. However, they also sparked my interest in reading history books. That’s why, even though I was only in my first year of high school, I was already reading books on World History, a subject we were only supposed to study in our fourth year.

My mother’s responses to the questions ignited by that photo left me hanging. I wanted to know why people with darkened skin were treated with such disgust in America and if the same was true in other parts of the world.

Why was that? Did Black people do something wrong to be treated the way the Whites did? Is it a sin to be dark-skinned? As I continued my inquiry and studied more historical facts, I realized that my grandmother’s instructions about white fabrics and colored ones mirror how society categorizes people based on skin color.

I thought that reading would help me understand why such practices existed in that part of the world at that time. But it didn’t. Yes, it was true that the more I read, the more I learned. However, the more I learned, the more confused I became. My questions only multiplied. My hunger for the answers to those questions became hard to satisfy.

I wanted to ask my mother why she didn’t just tell me outright that Whites once enslaved Black people. The latter were considered not as fellow human beings but as animals on a leash. I was wondering, then, how come America was called the land of the free when there were people chained in slavery? That was my first lesson in irony.

I learned that the Americans were British colonists who revolted against their king in England and went on to found their nation, the United States. The British and other Europeans were the ones who brought persons of color from Africa to the North American continent as slaves to serve them and work in their farmlands. The Europeans took the continent from another group of people of color, the Native Americans, through conquest, displacement, and violence.

Admittedly, there was so much I didn’t know about the history of the world. So, I read more. That’s when I realized that the more I  read, the more I learned that I was ignorant about many things. That’s when I also figured out that reading doesn’t always provide answers. Sometimes, it makes you ask more questions. And the answers to your questions can make you wonder, laugh, get angry, disgusted, or even feel compassion. You will experience a range of mixed emotions. Sometimes, you’ll get overwhelmed by them.

But most importantly, it helps you differentiate right from wrong. It enables you to recognize that the world is a battlefield where the forces of good and evil are constantly at odds. It was through reading that I learned that subjecting people to slavery is wrong, and those who perpetrate slavery belong to the forces of evil. It’s a simplistic but straightforward construct that formed in my young mind, and it developed in me a deep sympathy for Black people.

More readings led me to discover that while slavery dates back to antiquity, nothing was more pronounced than the plight of dark-skinned slaves. They suffered the most from it. An article I read posited that “people who were enslaved throughout history were considered inferior, uncivilized, and bestial. No race was stigmatized this way more than people of African descent. The Americans, in particular, consider them as a distinct group of people fashioned by nature for hard labor. They view Black people as innately and ineradicably inferior.” It was like they believed that God is loving and merciful, but they think that He created the dark-skinned people to become the servants of the fair-skinned ones.

In the images I saw in my continued reading, black people were not only separated from those with lighter skin, but some were chained at the neck, hands bound, and dragged by white men like animals. Others were kicked, slapped, or punched. Some had ropes around their necks, not being dragged but hanging from trees. Tongues out. Dead. Surrounded by tall, fair-skinned people holding clubs and guns. Some stood with hands on hips, smiling while proudly looking at the lifeless bodies of their victims. It’s hard to comprehend how anyone could smile while behind them hung the lifeless bodies of black men and women.

Again… Why?

Worse, I read that Black women were allegedly taken advantage of. That’s how brutal the Whites were. They mistreated and abused people of color. I wish it weren’t true. I hoped historians just made those things up. I wish the images I saw were just drawings, so nicely drawn that they appeared very realistic.ticular, considered them as a distinct group of people fashioned by nature for hard labor. They viewed black people as innately and ineradicably inferior.

The Fabrics of Race (2)

The Fabrics of Race (3)

BOOK: “A Paradigm For Self-Improvement”

My book, “A Paradigm For Self-Improvement: Unleashing Your Strongest Self,” is available at Amazon-KDP in paperback and e-book formats. If you have a Kindle account, you can read it for free.

This book offers a transformative personal growth and development framework, blending timeless wisdom with actionable strategies. This book helps unlock the attitudes, beliefs, skills, abilities, practices, and activities needed to unleash your full potential.

This comprehensive guide, which covers topics ranging from building self-belief and mastering time management to conquering self-doubt and cultivating lifelong learning, empowers you to take control of your journey. Each chapter is thoughtfully crafted to inspire reflection and action, helping you overcome challenges and achieve your goals. This book also includes a self-assessment designed to determine the extent of your adherence to self-improvement principles.

Whether seeking clarity in a chaotic world, resilience in the face of adversity, or the discipline to pursue your dreams and ambitions, this book provides the tools and insights to help you achieve success, health, and happiness.

Discover the paradigm shift that will unlock your strongest self and guide you toward the life you’ve always envisioned.

Take the first step toward unleashing your full potential—buy A Paradigm for Self-Improvement today and start your transformative journey toward success and fulfillment!

When Do We Wake Up?

(LAST OF 4 PARTS)

FILIPINOS’ HAMARTIA

The first three parts of this series of articles identified our serious faults as Filipinos—we sell our votes, we use questionable standards when choosing leaders, we treat elections as if they are popularity contests, allowing immensely popular but inexperienced and incompetent celebrities to win, and we either keep restoring the same traditional politicians from the “recycle bin” or replace them with family members. It is a “hamartia” (or tragic flaw) in our character as a nation.

Our inability to choose the right leaders clearly prevents us from reaching our full socio-political and economic potential as a nation.

We know the government is essential in leading all efforts to make our country progressive. We need the best leaders if  we really want to become a “developed nation.”  We as citizens are responsible for selecting the best ones to hold the reins of government. Unfortunately, we keep failing to do so.

The funny thing is that after we put them into power—the politicians who won because they had the money to buy votes, celebrities-turned-politicians who are inexperienced and incompetent, “recycled politicians” and the members of their political dynasties—we expect them to perform well. After every election, we expect a better-performing government.

And why would we expect a different government – a more effective one – when we know that we keep electing the same politicians or use the same old rotten standards when choosing new leaders?

Let us revisit  Albert Einstein’s definition of  insanity: “Doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting a different result.”

But assuming that one day we restore our sanity and finally refuse to sell our votes—finally, we learn to elect the most deserving and qualified candidates into office—would the wheels of national development start rolling?

Not quite yet!

There’s one more problem, a problem more serious than our failure to vote wisely and conscientiously. The more serious problem of Filipinos, as mentioned in the first part of this series, is the mindset that the leaders we elect are solely responsible for solving all of our society’s ills and the nation’s problems.

We view our relationship with the state from the vantage point of “self-entitlement.” We think that our leaders must give us “this and that.” We say the government should do “this and that” for us. We expect too much from leaders whom we don’t even choose using the best and most appropriate standards.

Is it the duty of the government to provide each citizen with food, clothes, and shelter?

There goes another problem among us Filipinos. We answer “yes” to the foregoing question, and we seem to have embraced another dangerous tendency—the “ayuda mentality.”

The government’s general functions are to formulate, implement, and enforce the laws of the land, build infrastructure, ensure peace and order, and create economic and other opportunities that help its citizens enjoy the conveniences of life, have the best chance to get a good education, and find or create means of livelihood.

It is also not the duty of the government to provide everybody with a job.

One of the functions of the government is to create an environment that promotes economic growth. They have to ensure that businessmen would be encouraged to invest and initiate business activities, thus creating job opportunities. But jobs are not given on a silver platter. We have to search for job openings, apply, and ensure that we have the required qualifications for the jobs we want. Getting ourselves ready for employment is a personal responsibility. The government will not deliver to our doorsteps the jobs that we want.

The government is also an employer but cannot possibly provide each citizen with a job. It is also impossible for the private sector to employ everybody. That’s just the reality—harsh as it may be. Those who don’t get employed or do not want to work for others because they have better plans for themselves could perhaps succeed as entrepreneurs.

Not everybody would get a college degree. Not everybody is trained and destined to be in a workplace – either in the corporate world or the academe. Some of us will be factory workers, sales clerks, farmers,  fishermen, plumbers, drivers, gardeners, or what-have-you. It doesn’t matter what jobs we have, as long as they are decent and they allow us to earn a living honestly.

Don’t reason out that you came from a poor family and your parents could not send you to school to get a good education and have a better chance for a better life.

Unfortunately, this is how we are wired. When we encounter failure, when things don’t turn the way we expect them to, when we are not doing well in the different areas of our personal lives, we are always ready to check our “blame list” to find somebody or something to put the blame on. And our favorite whipping boy – the government. When we are done accusing our leaders for not doing their job well, causing us to become losers, we next vent our ire on our parents, saying that they did not work hard enough to ensure that we live a good life when we become adults.

We need to throw away that “blame list” because, whether we like it or not, we are personally responsible and accountable for our successes and failures. There comes a time in our lives when we should become self-sufficient, when we, not the government nor our parents, decide for ourselves and take complete control of our destiny.

We Filipinos must realize that without recognizing our faults and changing, this country will never become progressive and “developed.” We will never gain the respect of the community of nations if we remain the way we are now.

John F. Kennedy said something we should reflect upon: “Ask not what your country can do for you—ask what you can do for your country.”

We Filipinos need to realize that there are two requirements for a country to become progressive and developed: good government and responsible citizens. Remove one, and a nation is doomed. The citizens and their leaders need to work harmoniously towards achieving national goals. There’s no other way. Both of them need to work hard. They have to work hand in hand. And in case you did not notice, we as citizens control both requirements – we can decide to become responsible as citizens and also choose in whose hands we should put the reins of government.

PART ONE (THE CURSE OF VOTE BUYING)

PART TWO (CLOWN-GRESS)

PART THREE (SAME POLITICIANS…SAME RESULTS)

When Do We Wake Up?

(THIRD OF 4 PARTS)

SAME POLITICIANS… SAME RESULTS

We’re complaining about political dynasties, right? But haven’t we realized we are guilty of creating the political dynasties in the Philippines? Yes, we have to admit it. We allowed the same politicians and their family members to lord it over in the Philippine political landscape.

When a politician, let’s say a mayor, could no longer run for re-election due to term limits, what would the honorable gentleman do? Turn his back on politics? Of course not! Power is so addicting. So many of those who experienced being at the helm of either local or national politics (and enjoyed the benefits, including those “passed under the table”) would not just quit politics or pass the torch to another person.

So, what would happen?

His wife would run for the position he previously held. Then that politician would run for another post –  as governor, perhaps. Most of the time, Filipino voters would allow them to win, and usually, they would be able to mesmerize (or buy) the voters to luckily get re-elected until they reach their term limits. Would it be the end? Would their thirst for power (and the so-called “benefits”) be finally satiated?

You know the answer… a resounding NO.

The couple would ask their son or daughter (a grandson, a granddaughter, or an in-law) to run for the positions they would vacate. The shocking thing (and you might not believe it) is that there are times when siblings, or even husbands and wives, do not give way to the other, and so members of the same family slug it out in the political arena.

Anyway, this is not about family members squabbling in the political arena but about the political dynasties their families created.

Let’s continue, then.

Let’s return to the mother who just reached her term limit as mayor. Would she go back to being a full-time mother and wife? You were born only yesterday if you don’t know the answer to that question. Yes – she would run for the post vacated by the husband-politician. The husband would then aim for a higher position  – run as congressman or senator. If all family members win, then for years, the power will change hands within the same family. The son (or daughter) is a mayor, the mother a governor, and the father either a congressman or senator. When term limits are reached, they will just run for the position a family member would vacate. Some siblings, and even in-laws, in the family also occupy minor positions in their geographical units.

Did that family create their political dynasty? No! We did it. We Filipinos created the political dynasties in the Philippines.

Now, answer these questions – “How (did they perform) are they performing  as leaders?” “What is the country’s current economic, social, and political condition?” “Is the Philippines  marching towards progress with them holding the reins of government for God knows how long?”

Of course, you know the answers to the foregoing questions.

How many of the available positions in the Philippine government, local and national, are held by the same families who have been the gods and goddesses of Philippine politics since time immemorial? Most of them are offspring of the peninsular who survived  “America’s power grab” at the turn of the 20th century. Eventually, they stayed in the country and reaped the dividends. And it’s not only the politics that they dominate. With the enormous fortune they inherited from their Spanish parents/grandparents, they also control the country’s economy. That’s why  Filipinos sometimes jokingly ask – “Did the Spanish rule really end?”

Only a few pure-blooded Filipinos and foreign expatriates of Chinese origin who became wealthy when the Americans took their turn to colonize the Philippines had the financial resources to challenge the Spanish mestizos for political supremacy in the Philippines, especially after the Americans granted the Filipinos their independence after the World War II. Some of them succeeded, and when they experienced how intoxicating power is, they (and their offsprings)  kept running, and we kept electing them as if nobody else were qualified.

It is no longer surprising that politicians holding national positions have one or two family members and in-laws holding seats in the local government.

Filipinos might ask, “When would the same people from the same families pass the reins of leadership to each other in national and local governments after elections end?”

That’s up to the Filipino voters.

So, we should not wonder why the World Bank still classifies the Philippines as a “developing country.”

According to Albert Einstein, “insanity” is doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting a different result.

Why do we expect a better-performing government when we keep electing the same politicians?

PART 4 (FILIPINOS’ HAMARTIA)

PART TWO (CLOWN-GRESS)

PART ONE (THE CURSE OF VOTE BUYING)